EV Pros and Cons: What to Consider Before Buying an Electric Vehicle

EV Pros and Cons: After extensive discussions on EV technology, we’ve recognized our audience’s interest in embracing disruptive technologies like electric vehicles (EVs). In response, we’ve decided to introduce a dedicated section for EV enthusiasts. To kickstart this initiative, our senior editors have compiled a pioneering report on Electric Cars in India, specifically focusing on models priced below ₹3.5 million (35 lakhs). This comprehensive report will delve into the advantages and disadvantages of these EVs, offering valuable insights for both seasoned adopters and those new to this exciting realm of transportation. Stay tuned for a deeper exploration of the pros and cons of electric cars in India’s evolving automotive landscape.

EV Pros and Cons MG comet 

Pros

Ultra-Compact Size and Maneuverability: The MG Comet boasts an ultra-compact size, making it ideal for navigating through tight city streets and crowded parking spaces. Its light steering and small turning radius of just 4.2 meters make it incredibly easy to maneuver, making city driving a breeze. This feature is particularly useful for urban commuters and those who need a nimble car for daily errands.

Well-Built and Affordable Hatchback: The MG Comet is described as a well-built hatchback, emphasizing its build quality and overall construction. Despite its affordability, it doesn’t give the impression of being cheaply made. This means that buyers can enjoy the benefits of an electric vehicle without compromising on the quality of the vehicle itself.

Customization Options: MG offers an extensive range of options for personalizing your Comet. With over 250 combinations of stickers, graphics, and designs, you have the freedom to make your car truly unique and reflective of your personal style. This level of customization allows owners to express themselves and stand out on the road.

Cons

Lack of Underbody Protection: While the MG Comet offers a decent ground clearance of 165mm for a vehicle of its size, there is a concern regarding the protection of the motor and rear differential located underneath. These critical components could be vulnerable to damage from road debris or obstacles since they may lack proper underbody protection. This could potentially lead to maintenance issues and costly repairs.

Zero Boot Space with Rear Seats Up : One significant drawback of the MG Comet is the absence of usable trunk space when all the rear seats are in the upright position. This limitation means that if you have passengers in the back, you won’t have any designated space for luggage or cargo. To accommodate any sizable amount of luggage, you’ll need to fold down the rear seats, which may not always be convenient.

2-Door Design and Limited Rear Seat Access: The MG Comet features a 2-door design, which can make accessing the rear seats more challenging compared to a 4-door configuration. This can be inconvenient for passengers getting in and out of the rear seats, especially in tight parking spaces. Additionally, it’s important to note that the Comet is a 4-seater, not a 5-seater, which means it lacks the flexibility of carrying a fifth passenger.

High-Speed Stability and Highway Suitability: The MG Comet may not provide a stable and comfortable experience at high speeds, and as a result, it’s not recommended for highway driving. This limitation might restrict its use for longer commutes or intercity travel, where maintaining stability and safety at higher speeds is essential.

 Key specifications and details of the MG Comet electric car

EV Pros and Cons Tata Tiago Ev 

Pros 

 Good Value for Money: The Tata Tiago EV is considered a good value-for-money option. This means that it offers a competitive price point in its segment while providing desirable features and capabilities. For consumers, this translates into getting a lot of bang for their buck when choosing the Tiago EV.

Amazing 8-Speaker Harman Audio System: One of the standout features of the Tata Tiago EV is its premium 8-Speaker Harman audio system. Harman is renowned for delivering high-quality sound experiences, and having an 8-speaker setup enhances the in-car entertainment for passengers, providing a rich and immersive audio experience.

Higher Top Speed for Highway Safety: Despite being in the same price range as the Citroen eC3, the Tata Tiago EV boasts a higher top speed. This higher top speed can enhance safety during highway overtaking maneuvers. It means that the Tiago EV has the capability to accelerate and pass other vehicles on the highway more confidently and swiftly, potentially reducing the time spent in the oncoming traffic lane, which is a safety advantage.

Cons 

 Slightly Lower Ground Clearance: The Tata Tiago EV features a ground clearance of 165mm when unladen. While this ground clearance may be acceptable for many driving conditions, some users might find it slightly lower than expected for a vehicle of its size. This could potentially result in occasional scraping or contact with speed bumps or rough road surfaces.

 Dated Interiors: Some users have expressed that the interiors of the Tata Tiago EV appear dated. However, it’s important to note that this perception is often balanced by the fact that the interiors are considered to be in line with the vehicle’s price range. In other words, while the design may not be the most modern, it is reflective of the car’s affordability.

 Lacks Underbody Protection: A notable drawback mentioned is the absence of underbody protection for the Tata Tiago EV. Without adequate shielding for the undercarriage components, there could be concerns about potential damage from road debris or obstacles, which may necessitate costly repairs or maintenance.

Key specifications and details of the Tata Tiago Ev 

EV Pros and Cons Citroen eC3 

Pros 

Highway Stability: The eC3 demonstrates good stability when driving on highways. This means that the vehicle is designed to handle well at higher speeds, providing a comfortable and secure driving experience during highway journeys.

Neat Integration of Battery Pack: The lithium-ion battery pack in the eC3 has been integrated neatly into the wheelbase of the vehicle. This integration not only maximizes interior space but also contributes to better handling. By distributing the weight of the battery evenly, it can enhance the vehicle’s balance and overall driving dynamics.

Underbody Protection: The eC3 features underbody protection that extends from the front to the back of the vehicle. This protection is crucial for shielding the undercarriage components from potential damage caused by road debris or obstacles. It can help prevent costly repairs and maintenance.

Ground Clearance: The eC3 offers a ground clearance of 170mm, which is considered good. While it’s slightly lower than the C3 (Citroen C3), it still provides sufficient clearance to navigate various road conditions comfortably. This ground clearance is particularly useful for tackling rough roads or speed bumps without scraping the undercarriage. 

Cons 

Cabin Material Quality: According to user reviews, the quality of cabin materials in the eC3 may not meet expectations. This suggests that the interior materials might feel less premium or durable compared to what is typically expected in a vehicle, potentially affecting the overall perception of quality.

Limited Cabin Width for Seating: The eC3’s cabin width may limit its interior space for passengers. While it comfortably accommodates four adults, it may not be as suitable for carrying five passengers. This could be a drawback for users who require seating for five individuals.

Limited Dealer Network: The eC3 currently has a small dealer network, which could result in limited options for after-sales support. A smaller network might mean less accessibility to service centers or authorized dealerships for maintenance and repairs, potentially inconveniencing owners.

Absence of Push-Start Option and Interior Suitability for Price Range: The absence of a push-start option in the eC3 may be considered a drawback, especially for those who prefer modern convenience features. Additionally, the interior design and quality may not align with the expectations of buyers in the 12-lakh price range. This discrepancy between the interior and the price point could impact the perceived value of the vehicle.

Key specifications and details of the Citroen eC3 

EV Pros and Cons Tata Tigor EV

Pros 

Amazing 8-Speaker Harman Audio System: The Tata Tigor EV features an impressive 8-Speaker Harman audio system. Harman is known for delivering high-quality sound experiences, and having eight speakers enhances the in-car entertainment for passengers, providing a rich and immersive audio experience.

Higher Top Speed Than Citroen eC3: The Tata Tigor EV boasts a higher top speed compared to the Citroen eC3. A higher top speed can be advantageous, especially for highway driving, as it provides better overtaking capabilities and a more comfortable experience when driving at high speeds.

Cons 

Tiago 24kWh Variant Considered Better Value: Many users have concluded that the Tiago 24kWh variant offers better value for money compared to other variants of the Tiago EV. This suggests that, in the eyes of these users, the 24kWh variant provides a more attractive combination of features, performance, and pricing.

Consideration of Upgrading to Nexon EV: Some users are contemplating upgrading to the Tata Nexon EV. This could be because they perceive the Nexon EV as a superior car in terms of features, performance, or other factors. The consideration of an upgrade may indicate that users are seeking a more advanced or premium electric vehicle experience.

Lacks Underbody Protection: A notable drawback mentioned is the absence of underbody protection for the Tata Tiago EV. This could raise concerns about potential damage from road debris or obstacles, which may require costly repairs or maintenance.

Key specifications and details of the Tata Tigor EV

EV Pros and Cons Tata Nexon EV Prime

Pros 

Well-Built Car with High Safety Rating: The Tata Nexon EV Prime is recognized for its robust build quality and impressive safety rating. This makes it an attractive choice for buyers who prioritize safety and durability in their vehicles.

Excellent Value for Money: The Tata Nexon EV Prime is considered a very good vehicle with a strong value proposition. Buyers get a lot for their money, including safety features, performance, and more.

Fun-to-Drive Experience: The Nexon EV Prime offers a fun-to-drive experience, thanks to its capable electric motor and the overall quality of the vehicle’s construction. Electric vehicles often provide instant torque, enhancing acceleration and driving enjoyment.

Premium Sound System by Harman: The inclusion of a high-quality sound system by Harman enhances the in-car entertainment experience, ensuring passengers can enjoy their favorite music with superior audio quality.

Generous Ground Clearance: With a ground clearance of 205mm, the Tata Nexon EV Prime is well-suited for tackling uneven road surfaces, speed bumps, and rough terrain. This feature adds to the vehicle’s versatility and ability to handle different driving conditions

 Cons

Panel Gaps and Rough Edges: Some users have reported the presence of panel gaps and rough edges in the vehicle. This could indicate minor manufacturing or finishing issues that may affect the overall aesthetic quality of the car.

Tire Grip and Wheel Spin: Users have provided feedback about the stock tires not providing sufficient grip for the motor’s power, resulting in wheel spin. This issue could potentially be addressed by installing wider tires with better traction. An electronic cutoff for tire spin, if not already implemented, could also help enhance control during acceleration.

Missing Adjustable Headrests: The absence of adjustable headrests for rear passengers is a concern raised by some users. Adjustable headrests are important for providing proper neck support and can be a safety feature in case of rear-end collisions (whiplash protection).

Exposed Orange-Wrapped Wires: Users have expressed concern about exposed orange-wrapped wires under the vehicle’s body. This is a safety concern as exposed wiring can be vulnerable to damage from road debris, moisture, or other external factors. Addressing this issue is essential to ensure the vehicle’s safety and longevity.

Key specifications and details of the Tata Nexon EV Prime

Mahindra Cons XUV400

Pros

Good Driving Experience: The vehicle offers a good driving experience, thanks to its responsive pedal and acceleration. The combination of these factors contributes to an enjoyable and dynamic driving experience, making it a pleasure to drive.

Very Good Tires: The vehicle comes equipped with very good tires. High-quality tires enhance traction, grip, and overall handling, improving the vehicle’s performance and safety.

Adjustable Headrests for Rear Passengers: Unlike some other models, this electric vehicle provides adjustable headrests for rear passengers. Adjustable headrests are important for providing comfort and safety, allowing passengers to customize their headrest positions for optimal support.

Spacious Boot Space: The vehicle offers a generous boot space of 378 liters. Ample boot space is valuable for storage and can accommodate a variety of cargo, making it suitable for various practical uses.

Cons 

Recall for Brake Potentiometer Issue: Some units of the vehicle were part of a recall in August 2023. The recall was related to checking for an “ineffective spring return action of the brake potentiometer.” Brake-related issues can be critical for safety, and this recall suggests there may have been concerns with the braking system that needed attention.

Bad Speaker and Sound Quality Complaints: There have been complaints about the speaker and sound quality in the vehicle. Issues with speakers can affect the overall audio experience and in-car entertainment. Users have expressed dissatisfaction with the sound quality, which can impact the overall driving experience.

Dated Interiors: Users have reported that the interiors of the vehicle appear dated. Dated interiors may not meet modern design and technology expectations, potentially affecting the perception of the vehicle’s overall quality and appeal.

Key specifications and details of the Mahindra Cons XUV400

EV Pros and Cons Tata Nexon EV Max

Pros 

Extended Range: The most prominent advantage of the Nexon EV Max is its extended range. With a larger battery capacity, it can offer a longer driving range on a single charge. This is particularly beneficial for daily commuting, long trips, or those who rely on their electric vehicle as their primary mode of transportation.

Reduced Range Anxiety: Longer range capabilities can significantly reduce range anxiety, which is a common concern among electric vehicle owners. With a substantial driving range, users can have more confidence that they won’t run out of battery power during their daily activities or journeys.

Versatile for Varied Driving Needs: A long-range electric vehicle like the Nexon EV Max can accommodate various driving needs. Whether it’s city commuting, highway driving, or inter-city travel, the extended range makes it a versatile option suitable for diverse use cases.

Reduced Charging Frequency: Longer range means less frequent charging. Owners can enjoy the convenience of fewer trips to charging stations, saving time and ensuring that the vehicle is ready for use when needed.

Environmental Benefits: As a primary vehicle with an extended range, the Nexon EV Max can contribute to reduced emissions and a smaller carbon footprint, especially if used for daily commuting or replacing a traditional internal combustion engine vehicle.

Potential Cost Savings: While the initial purchase price might be higher due to the larger battery, the reduced need for charging and potentially lower operating costs of an electric vehicle can result in long-term cost savings, making it an economically sensible choice.

Cons

Similar to Nexon EV Prime: The Nexon EV Max shares most of its cons with the Nexon EV Prime, suggesting that issues reported for the Prime model may also apply to the Max.

   Key specifications and details of the Tata Nexon EV Max

EV Pros and Cons MG ZS EV

Pros 

Good Driving Experience: The MG ZS EV offers a good driving experience with responsive pedals and acceleration. This can contribute to a dynamic and enjoyable driving experience.

Excellent Tires: Although mentioned as highly inflated, the tires on the MG ZS EV are considered very good. High-quality tires can enhance traction, grip, and overall handling, improving the vehicle’s performance and safety.

Positive User Responses to Design and Space: Users have provided lots of good responses regarding the overall interior and exterior design of the MG ZS EV, as well as its spaciousness. A well-designed and spacious interior can enhance comfort and satisfaction for passengers.

Full Underbody Protection: The presence of full underbody protection is a notable advantage. This protection helps shield the undercarriage components from potential damage caused by road debris or obstacles, reducing the risk of costly repairs.

Premium EV Option: The MG ZS EV is considered a great choice as a premium electric vehicle. It may appeal to buyers who prioritize premium features, design, and quality over value for money. Premium EVs often come with advanced features and a high level of refinement.

Cons

High Tire Pressure: The high tire pressure of 41 psi can lead to a less comfortable ride experience. This high pressure may result in increased vibrations, harshness, and a heightened sensitivity to irregularities on the road. It can affect the overall comfort of the vehicle, especially on less-than-perfect road surfaces.

Lack of Premium Features: Despite its price range, the MG ZS EV is reported to lack certain premium features. These include wireless CarPlay and Android Auto compatibility, auto-dimming interior rearview mirror (IRVM), and a better sound system. These features are commonly expected in premium vehicles and their absence may be a drawback for potential buyers.

 Key specifications and details of the MG ZS EV

EV Pros and Cons Hyundai Kona

Pros

Fun to Drive with Great Acceleration: The Hyundai Kona is described as fun to drive with great acceleration. This suggests that it offers an enjoyable and dynamic driving experience, which can be appealing to those who appreciate spirited driving.

Comes with Underbody Protection: The presence of underbody protection is a positive feature. Underbody protection helps shield critical vehicle components from potential damage due to road debris or obstacles, enhancing the vehicle’s durability.

Good Interior and Exterior Design: The Hyundai Kona is noted for having a good interior and exterior design. Attractive design elements both inside and outside the vehicle can enhance its overall aesthetics and visual appeal.

 Cons 

Low Ground Clearance: The Hyundai Kona is noted for having low ground clearance. This can potentially limit its capability to handle rough or uneven terrain and may result in the undercarriage being more vulnerable to damage from obstacles on the road.

Interior Lacks Space: The interior of the Hyundai Kona is reported to lack sufficient space. This limitation may result in a less comfortable and more cramped cabin environment, which can be a concern for both driver and passengers.

Smaller Size Compared to Some Competitors: The Hyundai Kona is described as being smaller in size compared to certain competitors, such as the ZS EV. This smaller size can impact interior space and may influence the vehicle’s suitability for specific use cases or preferences.

Not Ideal for Rear Passengers: The ride quality and seating for rear passengers are mentioned as less than ideal. This could affect the comfort and satisfaction of passengers in the rear seats, especially during longer journeys.

Not Enough Luggage Space: A reported drawback of the Hyundai Kona is that it may not offer sufficient luggage space. Limited cargo capacity can be a concern for those who require more room for transporting belongings, especially during travel or for daily utility.

 Key specifications and details of the Hyundai Kona

EV Pros and Cons BYD e6

Pros 

Long Range: The BYD e6 offers a long-range, which can be advantageous for those who require extended driving distances on a single charge. A longer range reduces the need for frequent charging stops.

Good for Chauffeured Transportation: The vehicle is noted as being good for chauffeured transportation. This suggests that it provides a comfortable and spacious interior suitable for passengers, making it a potential choice for rideshare or chauffeur-driven services.

Good Ride Quality: The BYD e6 is reported to have good ride quality due to its soft suspension setup. A soft suspension can help absorb road imperfections and provide a smoother and more comfortable ride for both the driver and passengers.

Neat Interiors: The interiors of the BYD e6 are described as neat. Neat interiors often convey a sense of cleanliness and organization, contributing to a pleasant in-cabin experience.

Cons 

Not Ideal as a Driver’s Car: The BYD e6 is mentioned as not being ideal as a driver’s car. This suggests that it may not offer the same level of driving excitement or sportiness that some drivers seek in their vehicles.

Lack of 7-Seat Configuration: It is noted that the BYD e6 could have offered a 7-seat configuration. The absence of a 7-seat option may limit its capacity for larger groups of passengers, which can be a consideration for families or those who require additional seating.

Key specifications and details of the  BYD e6

EV Pros and Cons BYD Atto 3 

Pros 

Very Comfortable Suspension: The BYD Atto 3 is noted for its very comfortable suspension setup. A comfortable suspension can enhance ride quality by reducing the impact of road imperfections, making it suitable for relaxed and comfortable driving experiences.

Interior Ergonomics and Quality: The vehicle is mentioned to have a good level of ergonomics and quality in its interior. This suggests that the design and layout of the interior contribute to a user-friendly and comfortable experience. Quality materials and craftsmanship can enhance the overall appeal of the cabin.

Cons 

Not Suited for High-Speed Driving: Due to its very comfortable suspension setup, the BYD Atto 3 may not be well-suited for high-speed driving. A very soft suspension can lead to reduced stability and handling at higher speeds, which may limit its performance on highways.

Divisive Interior Design: The interior design of the BYD Atto 3 is described as non-conservative, which means it has a unique and distinctive design. However, this design can be divisive, with some individuals loving it while others may not. Personal preferences regarding interior aesthetics can vary widely.

Missing Features: The BYD Atto 3 is noted as missing many features that are commonly expected in its price range. These missing features include wireless Android Auto and Carplay compatibility, ventilated seats, and rain-sensing wipers, among others. The absence of these features may be disappointing for buyers who expect a certain level of technology and convenience at this price point.

Limited Dealer Network: Currently, there is a mention of a small dealer network for the BYD Atto 3. A limited dealer network can potentially lead to challenges in terms of after-sales support, including service, maintenance, and access to spare parts. Buyers should consider the availability of dealerships and service centers in their area when evaluating the vehicle.

Key specifications and details of the BYD Atto 3 

Summary

This comprehensive analysis delves into the advantages and drawbacks of several electric cars, aiding prospective buyers in making informed choices. Each vehicle’s key attributes, price ranges, battery capacities, promised and dealer-quoted ranges, fast charging capabilities, battery warranties, estimated replacement costs, and safety ratings are meticulously examined.